You’re right. There is no right way to play. But there is a sort of unspoken rule that threads are only known to the people playing them unless otherwise stated. I don’t find any fault in your roleplay at all. It’s just this situation that is obviously uncomfortable for the other muse. Even the muse said you shouldn’t know and is trying to get your muse to drop it. You can do whatever you want and I can’t speak for them, but I know I’d feel awkward.

image

When that mun comes to me and says, please don’t, that’s when I listen. You, on the other hand, are … well. Stop shoving your preferences off on me.

And if you’re going to continue to hang around me, you want to check the rules of engagement page.

Once more, for posterity: I am not my muse. My muse is not me. Her reactions to things are not mine. And I do other muns the same courtesy.